Can You Add Comments to MathJax? Explained

By

PinLinkedIn

MathJax has become the go-to tool for rendering mathematical notation across the web. Whether in blogs, technical manuals, or scientific documents, it provides a seamless way to include beautiful, scalable math. But as formulas get longer and more complex, developers and educators alike may wonder: can you add comments to MathJax code to make it easier to understand or maintain?

TL;DR (Too Long; Didn’t Read)

Yes, you can add comments to MathJax, but it’s important to understand the method depends on the input format you’re using—either LaTeX or MathML. In LaTeX, comments can be added similarly to traditional LaTeX using the percent symbol (%), but only outside math expressions. For inline comments within math expressions, workarounds such as text mode or HTML-based comments are recommended. These approaches help keep code readable and maintainable without affecting the rendered output.

Understanding MathJax and Its Input Formats

MathJax supports multiple input formats with the two most common being:

  • TeX/LaTeX: This is by far the most popular method. Users familiar with LaTeX will feel right at home using this format for writing formulas.
  • MathML: An XML-based markup language for describing mathematical notations, often used in more semantically-rich environments.

The way you handle comments in MathJax depends significantly on which of these formats you’re using.

Using Comments in LaTeX with MathJax

LaTeX naturally supports comments using the % character. In a full LaTeX document, this is handy for hiding notes or documentation that shouldn’t be rendered. However, MathJax processes snippets of LaTeX code, generally within delimiters such as \(...\) for inline math or \[...\] for display math. This means that the % character behaves a bit differently.

Important highlights:

  • Comments using % must be placed outside math environments to avoid rendering errors.
  • Using % inside a math block might cause unexpected behavior since MathJax isn’t a full LaTeX parser.

For example, this will generally work:

// Outside math environment
% This is a comment explaining the next formula
\( a^2 + b^2 = c^2 \)

But placing a comment inside a MathJax block may break parsing:

\( a^2 + b^2 % This won't work \)

Workarounds to Comment Inside Math Expressions

Since inserting a traditional comment within a MathJax math expression can lead to errors, developers often use workarounds to simulate comments that don’t show up in the output but still give clues or hints in the source.

1. HTML Comments

If you’re embedding MathJax inside an HTML document, you can use HTML comments:

<!-- This formula calculates the area of a circle -->
\( A = \pi r^2 \)

These HTML comments are completely ignored by MathJax and won’t interfere with rendering.

2. Using \text{} for Inline Notes (Visible)

In cases where it’s useful for short comments to actually be visible in the rendered output—for educational or explanatory purposes—you can place those comments in \text{} blocks or tag them visually.

\( x^2 + y^2 = z^2 \quad \text{(Pythagorean theorem)} \)

However, it’s important to note that this method makes the comment visible to users, which might not always be the intent.

3. Data Attributes or Javascript Comments (Advanced)

For developers integrating MathJax with custom scripts, it’s also possible to use data- attributes on surrounding HTML tags or to keep comments inside script blocks containing MathJax TeX.

<script type="math/tex">
  % Advanced comment not shown in output
  a^n + b^n = c^n \quad \text{(Fermat's Last Theorem)}
</script>

This is more complex but allows for tighter integration and documentation in larger projects.

How About Comments in MathML?

MathML, being XML-based, offers a conventional way to insert comments using the standard XML comment syntax:

<!-- This is a MathML comment -->
<math xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML">
  <msup>
    <mi>a</mi>
    <mn>2</mn>
  </msup>
</math>

MathJax will completely ignore these comments in rendering.

Advantages:

  • Safer and standards-compliant commenting method for more structured documents.
  • Non-intrusive and does not interfere with the visual appearance.

Best Practices for Commenting in MathJax

Effective commenting in MathJax isn’t so much about whether it’s possible—it is—but about how to do it cleanly and without disrupting rendering. These best practices can help:

  • Keep comments outside of math environments wherever possible.
  • Use HTML comments in web-based environments for clarity and ease.
  • Use \text{} or \tag{} creatively if visible inline annotations are acceptable.
  • Stick to XML comments in MathML to maintain clean markup.

Should You Comment MathJax Code?

In collaborative environments like educational platforms, scientific blogs, and documentation sites, commenting MathJax code becomes essential. Whether it’s to explain why a certain formula is used, clarify variable roles, or note assumptions, comments improve readability and reduce maintenance headaches.

Especially in multilingual or collaborative projects where several contributors touch the same file, comments provide quick insight into the author’s original intentions.

Conclusion

While MathJax doesn’t support comments in the same way a traditional programming language might, there are plenty of ways to document and explain LaTeX and MathML code without interfering with rendering. It’s more of an art than a strict process, particularly since not all commenting methods are natively supported inside math expressions themselves. Understanding the safest and most effective ways to add comments leads to cleaner, more maintainable, and more professional documentation.

FAQ: Comments in MathJax

  • Q: Can I use % inside a MathJax formula to comment?
    A: No, it’s not recommended. Use it only outside the math block. Inside, it may cause parsing errors.
  • Q: Will HTML comments break MathJax parsing?
    A: Not at all. HTML comments like <!-- Note --> are ignored by MathJax and do not affect rendering.
  • Q: Is \text{} a valid way to add side comments within a formula?
    A: Yes, but those comments will be visible in the rendered output.
  • Q: How do I comment formulas in MathML when using MathJax?
    A: Use XML-style comments: <!-- This is a comment -->.
  • Q: Do comments affect MathJax performance?
    A: No, not significantly. Properly-placed comments are ignored and do not impact speed or output quality.
PinLinkedIn